Skip to main content

CSM Geophysics Field Camp 2011


** Things that I wrote below was exclusively taken from my personal notes / camera, thus miswriting of any technical related issues might occur which I don't give a damn - I considered myself as geo-journalist, I wrote based on what they had mentioned / showed. However I will make comments for some interesting notes that I have. I am hoping to inspire any young geoscientist to be creative but precise in paraphrasing their notes as what I will do now.


Located at Berthoud Hall 241, today at 9 am I attended the Geophysics (GP) Field Camp final presentation. The GP field camp is a mandatory field work course for junior Geophysics students at CSM. This year, students from Imperial College London (ICL) and Boise State University (BSU) are also participating in the field work. There are 50 students in total. Watching the final presentation, for sure, reminded me to GP field works that I have had back when I was undergrad. This 2.5 hrs presentation had great animo from non-participants (like me). There were at least 15 graduate students and 10 faculties in the room.


This year, field camp data is acquired at Neal Hot Springs in Vale Oregon. It involves everything from vibroseismic imaging for basement structure, to near-surface characterization for a better understanding of the geology and geothermal resources. The 4-week program is split somewhat evenly between 2 weeks field work and 2 weeks data processing/interpretation. Back in the day, the Geophysics field work used to run in 8 weeks - WTH !


The happy crew !


REGIONAL GEOLOGY


The study area is located in an arid area of eastern Oregon in a setting of complex and intersecting fault trends. A succession of basin fill sediments and intercalated lava flows have been repeatedly broken by episodes of basin formation and extensional faulting. This subsidence and deformational history has resulted in a complex map pattern of intersecting faults and fault blocks comprised of inter-layered sedimentary rocks and lava flows. Within this realm, the most recent faulting appears to have defined a down-faulted half-graben with a basin fill of Late Miocene lacustrine strata faulted against a heavily silicified and brecciated NW-SE striking normal fault. This fault zone is deeply dissected by Cottonwood and Bully creeks. Where the commingled streams cross the fault, defining the lowest exposure in the area, there is a surface hot spring with temperatures approaching boiling. Extensive surface alteration and silicification suggest the hydrothermal system has been in place for a long time, (perhaps millions of years I should say ?? - wild guess). We might guess that the geophysical investigations will be based on the hypothesis that cold meteoric waters arriving by regional drainage are saturating the fault zones in the area and that once waters have descend depths , they will heat to almost boiling and rise through convection and emerge as hot springs ??

Stratigraphic column of the local geology. Thanks to my junior mate, Gordon Welch, for sharing the jpeg. OBVIOUSLY not to scale.

Wells location plotted on top of topographic map. Thanks to my junior mate, Gordon Welch, for sharing the jpeg.

Theoretical half graben model (section A-A') at Neal Hot Springs. Thanks to my junior mate, Gordon Welch, for sharing the jpeg.


At the hot springs they encountered white chalky sinter (I have heard silica sinter from Geothermal course with Mr Nukee_boy, but not chalky sinter - any clue?) that are remnants of hydrothermal fluids that have reached the surface. North of the Neal Hot Springs they found surface expression of a normal fault that also appears to have some horizontal displacement. The orientation of the fault is N 15° W / 60°. To the west of the hot springs there are large outcrops of sedimentary rocks. They strike N 15° W and dip 21° in an eastward direction. These rocks are composed of white sediments that may be tuffs (not sure if it's correct, the guy next to me was on call - CRAP!). On top of the sediments there are well rounded volcanic rocks which may be traces of an ancient river (remember Stratigraphy course). Heading south from the sedimentary outcrops they encounter a contact between the sediments and andesites outcrops to the south. This is why Geology is important, mate !


A very obvious set of surface geology heterogeneity

Survey design were made by the juniors themselves ! Most of the lines targeted the big horst structure (red). I can't tell which one is what method's survey line - too complicated.

GRAVITY-GEOMAGNETICS

Objectives :

Neal hot springs and the surrounding area contains a variety of rock units and structural features. Potential field techniques depend on contrasts in rock properties, and therefore should be able to locate contacts between formations, and sharp contrasts in rock properties associated with faulting.

Magnetics: To show how magnetic surveys can be used to locate the boundaries between different geologic units and possibly identify the location of faults in the area.

Gravity: To gain an understanding of the regional structure in the area. This is important because the structure will ultimately control how the geothermal system works.

Gravity anomaly on topography. High anomaly founded on high topography which doesn't follow the Universal Gravitational of Newton's Law. Something weird down there - intrusion ? batholith ? horst ?

A not too bad forward modeling, tho I will question if it's logic to have such geological model. Too many polygons


I am not comfortable this magnetic field forward modeling. The mismatch between observed data and forward modeling data is too high. If they are trying to compare it with gravity, they should have recalculated the total magnetic intensity data as if the inducing magnetic field had a 90 inclination (a.k.a reduction to pole = RTP).


ELECTROMAGNETICS

Objective : To delineate regional structure surround the target area based on resistivity data.


A student brought the 50 pounds EM cable on his back. Life's never been so difficult.


Great EM inversion. They captured all of frequency band data with no errors. A fault-lookalike featured on the screen. At least we got better regional anomaly than magnetic and gravity do.


Resistivity tracing map shows that the low conductivity area correlates to area near hot spring.

GEOELECTRICITY - SELF POTENTIAL


Objectives :

Geoelectrity: Identify the permeable zone candidates surround the area. Two different fashions were done in complementary one to another (Wenner Alpha versus Dipole Dipole). The first configuration has better S/N and better horizontal structure identification. The second configuration has less S/N but better vertical structure identification. Using these configurations together will lead to better delineation of permeable zone.

Self Potential : Investigate the dominant fluid movement based on measured surface streaming potential. The positive versus negative self potential value indicate different type of movement (postive = expulsion, negative = injection / recharge).


Sweet correlation between SP versus Geoelectricity results. The upwelling (positive SP response) correlates with low DC resistivity, indicating some fluid has been moved toward surface.

Super clear fault boundaries on resistivity map

" So the recharge zone is dominantly on the north side of the area, while the upwelling zone is dominantly on the south side of the area. The lowest blueish anomaly is kinda awkward, we don't know what that is - LOL (she laughed loudly like hell) ", this was how the presenter present her interpretation. Zzz, kinda annoying.

3D isoresistivity map - but I don't understand the left handed pic, tho I like the right handed pic better.


SEISMIC

Objectives :

Deep seismic survey : basement structure identification

Near surface seismic survey : possible near surface fault/s delineation

Passive seismic survey (monitoring stations) : monitor fault activities, trace fluid motion, earthquakes monitoring

Vertical seismic profiling : vertical velocity mapping on a particular well.

Lacustrine sonar (ultra-seismic) survey : semi-offshore survey, water bottom identification.


Deep seismic data acquisition. Vibroseis was used as source.

I personally do not understand seismic processing that deep - but to come up with brute stack results for 2 weeks processing, I think that's pretty impressive.

No comment - the speaker was terrible, he talked too much + free fillers (19x per minutes). I did not understand what he was talking about.

Yayy - VSP data! No need to take core data (at least for shallow survey)

Monitoring stations surround the area. Even the Japan's recent earthquake was recorded in all stations (red lines).


I have never seen / learned sonar data, so I was quite impressed with results. Tho it works in super high frequency (hence the results are shallow ~ 30m), but the resolution is not that bad. I think they muted some part of the data (that's why you see the blocky whitish things?).

Beside methods I have written above there were other methods involved in this project, such as CSAMT, heat flow modeling, and paleomagnetic surveys. Some of the methods did not run well (such as CSAMT - they had mechanical issues with the instruments), some might have the data processed outside CSM (such as heat flow in Boise State University, or paleomagnetic in USGS). Among these method, I was surprised they run paleomagnetic survey in this area. I know that the paleomagnetic will extremely help them in age-rock correlation / dating. Other thing is its good control for magnetics data. Remember in magnetics we always assume that the remanent magnetic of the rock is zero (or have no impact on secondary magnetic field) --> which is not true. Thus, the additional information from paleomagnetic will constrain the magnetics model better.

By the end of the presentation, they concluded several finds related to regional structures, possible near surface faults, permeable zones, and prospect new geothermal drill based on this integrated geophysical project. I think it's pretty great for junior students. AWESOME !

Comments

  1. wee, ini kayak WS juga po sal ada banyak metode gitu? tapi keknya cuman ngolah data yah? ga akusisi data. kalo liat metodenya sih familiar yah, S1 geopis UGM mestinya juga bisa ini :D

    ReplyDelete
  2. haha, like this lah ting .. :)
    yup ini persis kayak WS, cuma waktu di lapangannya lebih lama ..

    ReplyDelete
  3. ihh wow..keren ya..apik.

    ReplyDelete
  4. menyimak.. dan moga2 paham.. (full english T,T)

    ReplyDelete
  5. hehe, you spend alot of time just for this, and this post really good. then i can compare much with the way me n friend's FC. hahaha... to bad for having modeling like that, but seem they really make it interactive n eyes cathing. that's most important. oke, let's us begin to report our best FC, more good modelling, more fun, more challenging, n best performing presentation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. yes - they actually did a great job (hey they're only bunch of juniors !)

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous6:23 PM

    Fey, kuwi gambar half graben-e kowe kan wes ahli (pas pendadaran)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why I hate stereotypes ?

I hate stereotypes. Why? Because it will drag you to become narrow minded in the way of your senses to respect a community. Some people called me terrorist, because I am moslem. Some people called me second level residence, because I am Asian. Some people called me nerd, because I don't drink and don't do shit.Stereotyping and generalization are the basic human being’s reaction. It’s subconscious and is triggered and formed based on our background, education, culture, social upbringing, etc. We can’t help it. And the judgment is personal, individual. Stereotyping is practiced by everyone about other communities or segments of the same community.

Although I hate it, stereotypes are inherent to human nature, and for good reason. We are all stereotypical of fire. We don’t touch it because we know it will burn us. We are told never to touch snakes because they are poisonous. So aren’t we being stereotypical when we don’t go near these things? Aren’t we being stereotypical when we …

Tipe Tipe Dosen Penguji Skripsi

Menurut saya menonton sidang skripsi itu seru dan penting. Seru, karena kita jadi bisa melihat muka nelangsa teman teman kita yang sedang asik dibantai para dosen penguji. Tentu sebagai seseorang yang pernah pendadaran, saya mengerti rasanya tekanan saat sidang dimana sejuta umat manusia beberapa dosen menguji hipotesis dan hasil penelitian saya. Ibarat dosen penguji adalah pemain liga voli, maka mahasiswa yang sidang adalah bola volinya: sering dioper sana sini dalam kebimbangan dan kegalauan. Penting buat ditonton karena sidang skripsi mengajarkan kepada kita bagaimana cara ngeles ala orang berpendidikan. Itu juga adalah momen dimana kita berhak memperjuangkan title geophysicist tanpa perlu bayar SPP dan BOP saben semesternya lagi. Selain itu penting juga buat belajar dari kesalahan orang lain saat sidang supaya kesalahan sama ngga terulang.

Namun, namanya lulus sidang skripsi itu susah susah gampang. Salah satu faktor penentunya adalah dosen penguji. Berikut adalah tipe tipe dosen p…

Review Beberapa Sidang Skripsi (Part 1)

Kalau di postingan sebelumnya sempat ngebahas tentang karakter dosen penguji skripsi, kali ini saya mau fokus me-review sidang skripsi yang saya tonton dalam 3 bulan terakhir. 
Memang sejak kembali ke Indonesia, ada sekitar delapan sidang skripsi S1, dimana lima diantaranya saya tonton. Alhamdulillah delapan mahasiswa ini lulus semua ~ ngga ada yang ngulang. Tiga sidang skripsi yang ngga saya tonton adalah sidangnya Kris'GF07, Gondes'GF06 dan Pai'GF06 - dan sumpah nyesel banget. Terutama skripsi Gondes yang konon dia merangkai dan membuat seismogram sendiri, dipasang di gunung Merapi sendiri, datanya diakusisi sendiri, hasilnya diolah sendiri, diinterpretasi sendiri. Bahkan instrumen seismogram yang dia pasang di gunung Merapi katanya uda hilang ditelan material vulkanik letusan besar tahun 2010 kemarin. Ebuset. Itu butuh pengorbanan waktu dan stamina banget lah. He embraced the philosophy of being a geophysicist. Sangat asolole.
Review yang akan saya berikan tentu saja sang…